Oct 18
Vol.
40
Issue 1

Article

Mission to Dismiss: A Dismissal of Rule 12(b)(6) and the Retirement of Twombly/Iqbal

One central aspect of this debate of costs raises questions about what accounts for the problem. Among the explanations advanced, the huge burdens attributable to discovery procedures usually top the catalog of the law profession’s grievances.

by Victor Marrero

Article

Widening the Lens: Refocusing the Litigation Cost-and-Delay Narrative

No one can deny that many aspects of litigation today are expensive and time-consuming or that lawyers are at least partially to blame for that; some lawyers have never met a motion they don’t like to make, while others insist on leaving no stone unturned in discovery.

by Arthur R. Miller

Article

The Narrative of Costs, the Cost of Narrative

Battles over procedure occur on multiple levels. At the most granular level, litigants, usually through lawyers, use procedural tools to advance their interests in individual cases. At the most abstract level, the procedural rules we select are products of a complex balance of intersecting and competing interests.

by Alexander A. Reinert

Article

Judge Victor Marrero’s Challenge to the Legal Profession: A “Little Rebellion Now and Then”

Judge Marrero’s Article is no ordinary Law Review Article. To begin with, it is ninety pages in length, written with passion and intensity. Its title targets practicing lawyers, but its content, upon close examination, challenges all parts of the legal profession.

by John D. Feerick

Article

The Cost of Rules, the Rule of Costs: A Practical Practitioner’s Perspective

From the perspective of courts, lawyers, and litigants in 1938, the new Federal Rules of Civil Procedure (Federal Rules) set out to advance the noble goal of “promot[ing] efficiency and lower[ing] litigation costs.”

by Sarah L. Cave

Article

Reducing the Cost and Increasing the Efficiency of Resolving Commercial Disputes

Among the central participants in commercial disputes—individuals or enterprises that become litigants, advocates, judges, court administrators, and the neutrals who are sometimes called in to help the parties negotiate resolutions—a near-consensus exists that resolving disputes generally costs too much and takes too long.

by John S. Kiernan

Article

The Virtues of Complexity: Judge Marrero’s Systemic Account of Litigation Abuse

At a time when too many are offering simplistic solutions to difficult problems, Judge Marrero has tackled one of the most intractable contemporary legal conundrums in a way that recognizes its multiple dimensions and complex underlying causes.

by Charles M. Yablon

Panel Transcript

PANEL TRANSCRIPT: CONTROLLING THE HIGH COST OF JUSTICE: PERSPECTIVES FROM THE FEDERAL JUDICIARY

Judge Marrero’s important scholarship recommends significant changes to the Federal Rules of Civil Procedure, and tonight we are honored to have with us Judge Robert Katzmann, Chief Judge of the U.S. Court of Appeals for the Second Circuit, who will serve as our moderator.

by Dean Melanie Leslie, Judge Victor Marrero, Chief Judge Robert A. Katzmann, Judge Loretta A. Preska, Judge Jed S. Rakoff, Judge John G. Koeltl, Judge Richard M. Berman

Student Note

O.K. Computer: The Devolution of Human Creativity and Granting Musical Copyrights to Artificially Intelligent Joint Authors

The same conclusion has repeatedly been reached: granting AIs copyrights is too speculative to consider seriously.

by Jared Vasconcellos Grubow

Student Note

A Fish Out of Water: Why the GAO’s Approach to Finding Agency Propaganda is Inadequate in the Social Media Age

Unfiltered by the press, President Roosevelt spoke to Americans as if having an intimate conversation in their homes during his fireside chats.

by Jennifer Pierce

Student Note

The Futility of Futility: An Analysis of the Charlie Gard Case Within the Framework of U.S. Law

It is extraordinarily difficult to determine the appropriate course of treatment for a child with a terminal illness. One possible approach is to assess the futility of all possible treatments. But what constitutes futility?

by Elana Bengualid

Issues Archive